By John H. Foote


I have written often about The Godfather Part II (1974) which I consider the finest film I have ever experienced, an American masterpiece. Oddly, I have not yet revisited The Godfather which I will remedy today.

“I believe in America”, are the first words we hear in The Godfather, spoken by a terrified undertaker who has come to ask the godfather, Don Vito Corleone, for a favor which cannot be refused on this day of his daughter’s wedding. The America this immigrant believes in, that he worked so hard to fit in too, has betrayed him and he has come to the old mafia chieftain for a justice he would never dream of getting in the courts of America. Vito Corleone (Marlon Brando) loves America too, and for the same reasons as the undertaker, though they move in very different circles. This one act will lock them on a path moving towards one another, a night when the godfather comes to ask for payback for his favor. And of course, that is the night Bonasera, the undertaker, dreads.

More than 45 years have passed since the releases of The Godfather and its sublime sequel The Godfather Part II which altered the course of filmmaking in North America and were embraced around the globe as the pinnacle of movie making on this continent. Like Citizen Kane (1941) before it, the films are hailed as the finest in American film history, the best in world cinema.

Mario Puzo had written the best seller “The Godfather” and Paramount Pictures had bought the film rights. Producer Robert Evans was assigned the film and hired recent Oscar winner Francis Ford Coppola to co-write the film and direct the picture. Did Evans know what he was getting into? Did he know the 32-year old Coppola would create one of the most astounding films in film history? Could he have anticipated the clashes with Coppola that became the stuff of legend?

From the beginning Coppola made it clear he would not be bullied or pushed around, and he was pretty aware that was why they had hired him, indeed, to bully and push him around! He would not have it. Working with Puzo he saw something deeper in the book that neither Evans nor Puzo had counted on, a chance to make a movie about America, about the immigrant experience, about a father and sons, and the perversity of the American Dream. Drawing on his own Italian heritage and relationship with his father and siblings, Coppola went for something very intimate, very deep, very personal, resulting in the most remarkable crime film ever made.

Marlon Brando

The studio had wanted for the role of Don Vito Corleone, the godfather of the title, actors such as Burt Lancaster, Ernest Borgnine, Frank Sinatra or, God help us, Laurence Olivier, which would have been grotesque. Coppola saw one man, Marlon Brando, as the 70-year old mafia chief but at that point in his career Brando was all but finished, reviled by the industry and studios, responsible for more than one film going radically over budget and over schedule. No one wanted to work with Brando, but Brando wanted the part and Coppola wanted Brando. The director convinced the actor to do a test, though he presented it to Brando as something else, but he got the man on tape nonetheless. Brando slicked back his hair, used some make up to make his eyes look sunken into his head, put cotton in his cheeks to flesh them out and spoke in a raspy, cigar scarred voice. No longer was Coppola looking at 47-year old Marlon Brando, instead he was looking at a 70-year old Italian mafia chief with the look of a bulldog. The studio chiefs saw the test, loved it, did not recognize the actor, and then were told it was Brando.

He was cast on the spot.

More fighting took place over the casting of the sons, with Jack Nicholson, Warren Beatty and even WASPish Robert Redford being offered roles in the film. Again Coppola fought for the actors he wanted, which included James Caan, Robert Duvall and John Cazale. For the plum role of Michael, the director wanted virtually unknown stage actor Al Pacino, but the studio refused, calling him “a midget”. Coppola held strong, and finally they backed down allowing the director to have his cast.

They fought once more, about the setting of the film which, as in the book, Coppola wanted to set it in the years right after the end of the Second World War. To save money the studio wanted it set in 1972, but both Coppola and Puzo stated their case and, as it made sense, the studio backed down. There would be many more fights between Coppola and producer Robert Evans, as Evans saw himself an artist which he clearly was not. The actors and crew made clear their devotion to Coppola, and the film, despite Evans interference, belonged to Coppola.

Even during filming Coppola was convinced he would be fired any day, and when Oscar winner Elia Kazan showed up set the young director thought it was a matter of days. Little did he know Brando had gone to the producers and made it clear if Coppola was fired, he would walk, lawsuit or not. So, finally Paramount left him alone to make the film and when it began previewing for the critics, there were not enough words to praise the picture. Concerned with the length Coppola cut some of it, but after seeing the cuts, Evans convinced him the film worked longer, and no one would complain about the length. He was spot on.

Hailed as the greatest American film since Citizen Kane, The Godfather opened in the spring of the year to amazing box office and rave reviews across the board. Within days of opening the film was already the stuff of legend, within three months it had passed The Sound of Music (1965) to become the highest grossing film in movie history, but even more it entered into the consciousness of America. Quotes from the film became part of the American lexicon, the soundtrack score from the picture sold millions of copies, and at years end the film began winning awards. Five Golden Globes, 10 Academy Award nominations, the DGA Award for Best Director and finally, the Academy Award for Best Picture, Best Actor, and Best Screenplay.

Coppola’s storytelling is patient, drawing us into the film by showing us the love the Corleone family has for one another at the wedding of Connie, the intimacy they share with their close friends and extended family. When an attempt is made to assassinate Vito, and slowly Michael realizes the men who shot him are not going to be stopped, he is drawn into the family to help his father, gunning down the men responsible in a restaurant in one of cinemas most famous scenes. From that moment on, Michael becomes the heir apparent to the seat of the godfather, groomed for taking over the family by his father and adopted brother Tom Hagen. He will prove more ruthless than his father, brilliantly, like a fine chess player, eliminating the heads of the four other families in one fell swoop, on one afternoon. God he even has his brother-in-law killed for setting up Sonny years earlier.

Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer.

And Michael does just that.

When his father dies, he knows someone will come after him and that someone will be close to him and a traitor. When it is Tessio, who has been loyal to his father for years, Michael does not hesitate to have the old man killed, knowing it was not personal, just business.

In the final moments of the film, Michael lies to his wife Kay, one of many he has told her and one of many he will continue to tell her. Kay watches through a crack in the door as Clemenza kisses his hand and calls him Don Corleone, and at that moment Kay knows he has lied to her and is the same kind of man as his father, a man he once vowed never to be. He has solidified his power by having killed the heads of the other mafia families in the days before he moves his own family and interests to Las Vegas, where he is the most powerful chieftain in the country.

There are so many great moments in the film, the opening, the wedding in which we are slowly introduced to the family, the shooting of the Don, the famous killing of Paulie (“leave the gun, bring the cannoli”), Michael gunning down Sollozzo and McCluskey in the restaurant, the horrifying massacre of Sonny, Tom Hagen telling the Don of Sonny’s death, the trembling Don looking upon the destroyed body of Sonny and saying to the undertaker, “See how they massacred my boy”, nearly falling apart, the Don’s paralyzing speech to the members of the Five Families, the death of the Don in the garden, and Michael solidifying his power by killing the other heads of the major families. Mixed in with these startling set pieces is a remarkable story of a father and his sons, his love for his boys and theirs for him, willing to do murder for him.

James Caan Marlon Brando Al Pacino and John Cazale

The Godfather was nominated for 10 Academy Awards including four for acting. Brando was nominated and won for Best Actor while James Cann and Robert Duvall were up for supporting actor. Incredibly, dominating the film, Pacino was nominated for supporting actor, though he should have been in the Best Actor category. Brando is onscreen for under thirty minutes, while Pacino dominates the movie. To say a star was born is an understatement, he would go on to be one of the finest actors in American cinema, at least in the seventies.

Pacino’s evolution from idealistic war hero, wanting nothing to do with the family business, turned cold blooded killer and ruthless head of the family is an astounding piece of film acting. It is all in the eyes, and we see him become icy cold, merciless, we watch as his very presence radiates a danger even Brando does not project, or perhaps chooses to disguise.

Brando is remarkable as Don Vito, a powerful and dangerous man who carries his power easily. There is a telling cut from one of the most famous scenes in the film. Jack Woltz awakens to find a horse head in his bed, a dire warning from the family Corleone, and the next cut we see is of Vito enjoying his morning, blissfully aware that he has sent a harsh message, knowing he will achieve the desired result.

The rest of the cast are superb, from James Caan’s hot headed Sonny, John Cazales’ weak Fredo through to Diane Keaton as Kay, Michael’s tortured wife. It is simply a flawless work, surpassed in American cinema only by its sequel, the extraordinary The Godfather Part II. That Coppola could make a film that surpassed the genius of The Godfather is a testament to his own genius. By creating a film more complex, darker and more powerful than the first he would cement his own reputation as the cinema’s greatest director.

Leave a comment